New theoretical framework reveals hidden complexity in black hole ringdown signals

In a recently published paper in Physical Review Letters, scientists propose a comprehensive theoretical framework indicating that gravitational wave signals from black hole mergers are more complex than earlier anticipated.

When two black holes merge in the cosmos, the cataclysmic event doesn’t end with a simple collision. The newly formed black hole continues to vibrate like a struck bell, producing gravitational waves in what scientists call the “ringdown” phase.

Researchers found that the cosmic reverberations involve sophisticated quadratic mode couplings—secondary oscillations that develop when primary modes interact with each other. This nonlinear behavior had been predicted in Einstein’s theory of general relativity, but has never been fully characterized until now.

“I am always fascinated by various nonlinear phenomena in general relativity,” Huan Yang, co-author from Tsinghua University, told Phys.org. “Over the past [few] years, the theoretical tools for studying nonlinear perturbations of black holes have gradually become available, so I started to look at the nonlinear ringing of black holes.”

The work resolves a long-standing discrepancy between theoretical predictions and numerical simulations of black hole behavior, marking what Yang describes as a “success” of second-order perturbation theory.

Beyond quasinormal modes

When black holes merge, the resulting object doesn’t immediately settle into a stable state.

Instead, it oscillates in characteristic patterns called quasinormal modes (QNMs)—natural frequencies at which the black hole vibrates as spacetime curvature gradually relaxes back to equilibrium.

Previous studies focused primarily on these linear modes. However, general relativity predicts that in extreme gravitational environments around black holes, these modes should interact and generate secondary oscillations.

“Gravity is described by general relativity, which is a nonlinear theory,” Yang explained. “Gravitational waves propagating in the spacetime generally interact with each other, and this interaction is particularly strong around black holes, where the spacetime curvature is large.”

The research team developed two independent analytical methods to analyze these interactions: a complex contour technique and a novel hyperboloidal time-slicing approach. The latter avoids mathematical complications by using specialized coordinate systems that allow direct treatment of the governing equations.

Ultimately, their goal was to classify and identify all possible interactions or coupling channels—the different ways that primary oscillation modes can combine to produce secondary signals.

Resolving theoretical tensions

The researchers identified four distinct channels, labeled by how the parent modes contribute to the quadratic effects.

Remarkably, they found that a particular channel, one in which both parent modes contribute with negative coefficients, invariably disappears entirely, irrespective of the black hole’s characteristics. The discovery stems immediately from the mathematical architecture of the foundational equations and establishes a basic constraint governing black hole behavior.

“The calculation is based on the theoretical framework called ‘Black Hole Perturbation Theory,’ which is over fifty years old,” explained Yang. “As a new development in the nonlinear regime, it makes predictions that should be consistent with fully numerical simulations.”

The consistency between their theoretical predictions and existing simulations validates the approach after earlier work had shown puzzling discrepancies.

“I’d like to emphasize that such tests are important, as in our earlier work last year, we had inconsistent results due to missing channels,” noted Yang. “That motivated us to recognize and classify different coupling channels.”

Observational prospects

The theoretical advance comes at a crucial time for gravitational wave astronomy. Current detectors like LIGO and Virgo operate near the threshold where these subtle secondary signals might be detectable, while next-generation instruments promise dramatically improved sensitivity.

The researchers conducted a comprehensive survey to assess which quadratic modes would be observable with different detector configurations.

Their analysis reveals that several secondary signals could achieve signal-to-noise ratios above 8–10 with planned ground-based detectors like Cosmic Explorer, while space-based missions like LISA show promise for detecting other mode combinations.

“To pick up these nonlinear signals, we need devices that can accurately probe the binary black hole merger process, especially in the ringdown stage,” Yang explained.

“Space-borne detectors (like LISA) and third-generation ground-based detectors (like Cosmic Explorer) will be our best tools to probe black hole ringdowns, possibly with signal-to-noise ratios of up to hundreds.”

The team identified optimal conditions for detection: Moderate mass ratio binary systems with maximally spinning black holes provide the strongest signals. For ground-based detectors, total system masses around 60–80 times our sun’s mass offer the best prospects.

Future frontiers

The capability to identify and examine these nonlinear behaviors would deliver exceptional experimental verification of general relativity in severe gravitational regimes. Discrepancies between observed and predicted coupling strengths might indicate physical phenomena that transcend Einstein’s hundred-year-old theory.

The work also opens multiple research directions for understanding black hole physics. Yang foresees progressing past quadratic effects to comprehensively describe the entire breadth of nonlinear behaviors in black hole ringdown processes.

“There are various kinds of nonlinearities in black hole ringdowns; the quadratic mode is just one of them,” he explained.

“I believe once all these important nonlinear signals are understood, we can construct a ‘complete’ ringdown waveform that accurately describes the ringdown signal starting from the peak of the merger.”

© 2025 Science X Network